| Year |
Winner |
Team |
Match, Round,Ground |
| 1970 |
Alex Jesaulenko |
Carlton |
Carlton vs Collingwood, Grand Final day, Melbourne Cricket Ground |
| 1971 |
Alex Ruscuklic |
Fitzroy |
Fitzroy vs Carlton, Round 10, Princes Park |
| 1972 |
Peter Knights |
Hawthorn |
Hawthorn vs Collingwood, Round 17, Glenferrie Oval |
| 1973 |
Alan Atkinson |
Collingwood |
Collingwood vs Hawthorn, Round 21,Waverley park |
| 1974 |
Billy Picken |
Collingwood |
Collingwood vs Richmond, Round 9,Melbourne Cricket Ground |
| 1975 |
Peter Knights |
Hawthorn |
Hawthorn vs Carlton, Round 17, Princes Park |
| 1976 |
Billy Picken |
Collingwood |
Collingwood vs St. Kilda, Round 16,Victoria Park |
| 1977 |
Peter Knights |
Hawthorn |
Collingwood vs Hawthorn, Round 9,Princes Park |
| 1978 |
Phil Baker |
North Melbourne |
Hawthorn vs North Melbourne, Grand Final day, Melbourne Cricket Ground |
| 1979 |
Michael Roach |
Richmond |
Richmond vs Hawthorn, Round 5,Melbourne Cricket Ground |
| 1980 |
Graham Teasdale |
South Melbourne |
South Melbourne vs Collingwood, Round 7,Lake Oval |
| 1981 |
Peter Bosustow |
Carlton |
Carlton vs Geelong, Round 18, Princes Park |
| 1982 |
Geoff Raines |
Richmond |
Richmond vs Fitzroy, Round 2, Waverley park |
| 1983 |
Ken Hunter |
Carlton |
Carlton vs North Melbourne, Round 21,Princes Park |
| 1984 |
Denis Banks |
Collingwood |
Footscray vs Collingwood, Round 10, Western Oval |
| 1985 |
Gary Ablett, Sr. |
Geelong |
Geelong vs North Melbourne, Round 5,Kardinia Park |
| 1986 |
Gary Buckenara |
Hawthorn |
Hawthorn vs Carlton, Round 1, Waverley Park |
| 1987 |
Warwick Capper |
Sydney |
Sydney vs Hawthorn, Round 7, Sydney Cricket Ground |
| 1988 |
Stephen Silvagni |
Carlton |
Collingwood vs Carlton, Round 14,Melbourne Cricket Ground |
| 1989 |
Alastair Lynch |
Fitzroy |
Fitzroy vs North Melbourne, Round 16,Melbourne Cricket Ground |
| 1990 |
Michael Mitchell |
Richmond |
Richmond vs Fitzroy, Round 5, Melbourne Cricket Ground |
| 1991 |
Brett Allison |
North Melbourne |
North Melbourne vs Collingwood, Round 11, Melbourne Cricket Ground |
| 1992 |
Nicky Winmar |
St Kilda |
West Coast vs St. Kilda, Round 3,Subiaco Oval |
| 1993 |
Tony Modra |
Adelaide |
Adelaide vs North Melbourne, Round 8,Football Park |
| 1994 |
Gary Ablett, Sr. |
Geelong |
Collingwood vs Geelong, Round 7,Melbourne Cricket Ground |
| 1995 |
Shaun Smith |
Melbourne |
Brisbane vs Melbourne, Round 22,Brisbane Cricket Ground |
| 1996 |
Ben Hart |
Adelaide |
Adelaide vs St. Kilda, Round 8, Football Park |
| 1997 |
Tony Modra |
Adelaide |
Adelaide vs North Melbourne, Round 17,Football Park |
| 1998 |
Winston Abraham |
North Melbourne |
North Melbourne vs Port Adelaide, Round 18, Manuka Oval |
| 1999 |
Matthew Lappin |
Carlton |
Carlton vs Essendon, Round 1, Melbourne Cricket Ground |
| 2000 |
Tony Modra |
Fremantle |
Fremantle vs Geelong, Round 1, Subiaco Oval |
| 2001 |
Gary Moorcroft |
Essendon |
Essendon vs Western Bulldogs, Round 14,Telstra Dome |
| 2002 |
Jonathan Brown |
Brisbane |
Hawthorn vs Brisbane, Round 17, Melbourne Cricket Ground |
| 2003 |
Chris Tarrant |
Collingwood |
Collingwood vs Geelong, Round 18,Telstra Dome |
| 2004 |
Ashley Sampi |
West Coast Eagles |
West Coast vs Melbourne, Round 7,Melbourne Cricket Ground |
| 2005 |
Luke McPharlin |
Fremantle |
Fremantle vs West Coast, Round 3,Subiaco Oval |
| 2006 |
Brad Ottens |
Geelong |
Geelong vs Sydney, Round 5, Telstra Stadium |
| 2007 |
Michael Newton |
Melbourne |
Melbourne vs Kangaroos, Round 17,Telstra Dome |
| 2008 |
Matthew Lloyd |
Essendon |
Essendon vs Melbourne, Round 18,Melbourne Cricket Ground |
| 2009 |
Brett Burton |
Adelaide |
Carlton vs Adelaide, Round 22, Etihad Stadium |
| 2010 |
Liam Jurrah |
Melbourne |
Port Adelaide vs Melbourne, Round 21,AAMI Stadium |
| 2011 |
Andrew Krakouer |
Collingwood |
Collingwood vs Adelaide, Round 9, Etihad Stadium |
