Miss Pennsylvania USA | Miss Pennsylvania Teen USA
| Year | Name | Hometown | Age | Local Title |
| 2016 | ||||
| 2015 | Ashley Schmider | South Fayette | 23 | Miss Neshaminy Valley |
| 2014 | Amanda Smith | Dade City | 21 | Miss Southwestern Pennsylvania |
| 2013 | Annie Rosellini | Butler | 21 | Miss Greater Juniata Valley |
| 2012 | Jordyn Colao | Erie | 22 | Miss Freedom Forge |
| 2011 | Juliann Sheldon | Plum Borough | 21 | Miss Jewel of the West |
| 2010 | Courtney Thomas | Sigel | 21 | Miss Jewel of the West |
| 2009 | Shannon Doyle | Wilkes-Barre | 24 | Miss Armstrong County |
| 2008 | Kendria Perry | Pittsburgh | 23 | Miss Armstrong County |
| 2007 | Rachel Brooks | Broomall | 24 | Miss River City |
| 2006 | Emily Wills | Beaver | 24 | Miss Armstrong County |
| 2005 | Nicole Brewer | Philadelphia | 22 | Miss Allegheny Valley |
| 2004 | Victoria Bechtold | Johnstown | 21 | Miss Pittsburgh |
| 2003 | Candace Otto | Murrysville | 23 | Miss Three Rivers |
| 2002 | Autumn Marisa | Waynesburg | 22 | Miss Armstrong County |
| 2001 | Rosalyn Menon | Hazleton | 22 | Miss Three Rivers |
| 2000 | Melissa Jeka | Warminster | 23 | Miss Allegheny Valley |
| 1999 | Susan Spafford | Erie | 24 | Miss Southwestern Pennsylvania |
| 1998 | Mayra Acosta | Lewistown | 22 | Miss Southwestern Pennsylvania |
| 1997 | Heather Busin | Grove City | 20 | Miss Butler County |
| 1996 | GiGi Gordon | Butler | 23 | Miss Armstrong County |
| 1995 | Linette Mertz | Kutztown | 23 | Miss Susquehanna Valley |
| 1994 | Kirstin Border | Glen Rock | 24 | Miss State Capitol |
| 1993 | Diane Fabiano | Lansdale | 24 | Miss Southwestern Pennsylvania |
| 1992 | Judy Fitch | Dallas | 24 | Miss Wilkes-Barre/Scranton |
| 1991 | Linda O'Boyle | Dupont | 23 | Miss Wilkes-Barre/Scranton |
| 1990 | Marla Wynne | Easton | 23 | Miss Southwestern Pennsylvania |
| 1989 | Michelle Kline | Easton | 24 | Miss Wilkes-Barre/Scranton |
| 1988 | Denise Meyer | Pittsburgh | 21 | Miss Bedford |
| 1987 | Katarina Sitaris | Wilkes-Barre | 24 | Miss Wilkes-Barre/Scranton |
| 1986 | Darlene Deeley | Philadelphia | 25 | Miss Greater Wilkes-Barre/Scranton |
| 1985 | Lea Schiazza | Philadelphia | 23 | Miss Montgomery County |
| 1984 | Gina Major | Huntsville | 25 | Miss Lehigh Valley |
| 1983 | Jennifer Eshelman | Hegins | 23 | Miss Panther Valley |
| 1982 | Laurie Ann Hixenbaugh | Belle Vernon | 22 | Miss Washington County |
| 1981 | Jill Shaffer | Dover | 22 | Miss Lebanon |
| 1980 | Anita Ellen Patton | Lebanon | 21 | Miss Lebanon |
| 1979 | Carolyn Louise Black | Elizabethtown | 22 | Miss Lancaster County |
| 1978 | Charmaine Kowalski | State College | 22 | Miss Penn State |
| 1977 | Lynn Carol Grote | Bowmansville | 22 | Miss Lancaster County |
| 1976 | Marie McLaughlin | Levittown | 23 | Miss Lehigh Valley |
| 1975 | Connie Harness | Mechanicsburg | 20 | Miss Carlisle |
| 1974 | Karen Lynn Kuhn | Levittown | 20 | Miss Lower Bucks County |
| 1973 | Tina Louise Thomas | Lancaster | 18 | Miss Lancaster County |
| 1972 | Linda Olson | Corry | 20 | Miss Indiana University of Pennsylvania |
| 1971 | Maureen Wimmer | Perkasie | 20 | Miss Lower Bucks County |
| 1970 | Maggie Walker | Harrisburg | 18 | Miss York County |
| 1969 | Trudy Lee Pedersen | Etters | 18 | Miss York County |
| 1968 | Susan Robinson | Pittsburgh | 22 | Miss Pittsburgh |
| 1967 | Doris Ann Lausch | Lancaster | 20 | Miss Lancaster County |
| 1966 | Gale Veronica Rothwell | Philadelphia | 21 | Miss Germantown |
| 1965 | Judith Lynn McConnell | Pittsburgh | 21 | Miss Pittsburgh |
| 1964 | Marilyn Cutaiar March | Havertown | 19 | Miss Delaware County |
| 1963 | Cheryl Lynn Kegley | Salisbury | Miss Central Pennsylvania | |
| 1962 | Crystale Leigh Martin | Milton | 19 | Miss Susquehanna Valley |
| 1961 | E. Lynne Maloney | King of Prussia | 20 | Miss Montgomery County |
| 1960 | Priscilla Mae Hendricks | Shillington | 19 | Miss Reading |
| 1959 | Lois Janet Piercy | Springfield | 21 | Miss Centre County |
| 1958 | Rosalie Samley | Bethlehem | Miss Lehigh Valley | |
| 1957 | Jennie Rebecca Blatchford | Hollidaysburg | Miss Central Pennsylvania | |
| 1956 | Lorna Malcomson Ringler | Upper Darby | Miss Delaware County | |
| 1955 | Pam Ulrich | Sinking Spring | Miss Reading | |
| 1954 | Barbara Sue Nager | Philadelphia | Miss Greater Philadelphia | |
| 1953 | Evelyn Margaret Ay | Ephrata | 20 | Miss Lancaster County |
| 1952 | Miriam Smith | McAlisterville | Miss Susquehanna Valley | |
| 1951 | Clare Lippert | Tarentum | Miss Kiski Valley | |
| 1950 | Emile Longacre | Phoenixville | Miss Chester County | |
| 1949 | Marlene Carozzo | Kennett Square | Miss Chester County | |
| 1948 | Ruth Douglas | Harrisburg | ||
| 1947 | Dorothy Gresh | Williamsport | ||
| 1946 | Eleanor Kramer | Lebanon | ||
| 1945 | Timmy Weston | Clairton | ||
| 1944 | Margie Dorie | Pittsburgh | ||
| 1940 | Frances Marie Burke | Philadelphia | ||
| 1939 | Ruth Phyllis Willock | Pittsburgh | ||
| 1936 | Rose Coyle | Philadelphia | ||
| 1935 | Henrietta Leaver | Pittsburgh | ||
| 1927 | Florence Koons | |||
| 1924 | Ruth Malcomson | Philadelphia | ||
| 1924 | Katherine Brown | Altoona |