Miss New York America 2012
| Year | Name | Hometown | Age | Local Title |
| 2011 | Kaitlin Monte | Pittsford | 22 | Miss Southern New York |
| 2010 | Claire Buffie | New York City | 24 | Miss Southeast New York |
| 2009 | Alyse Zwick | Scarsdale | 23 | Miss Westchester County |
| 2008 | Leigh-Taylor Smith | New York City | 22 | Miss Brooklyn |
| 2007 | Elisabeth Baldanza | Oneonta | 23 | Miss Empire Rose |
| 2006 | Bethlene Pancoast | Brooklyn | 24 | Miss Heart of New York |
| 2005 | Kandice Pelletier | New York City | 24 | Miss Greater New York City |
| 2004 | Christina Ellington | New York City | 22 | Miss Southern New York |
| 2003 | Jessica Lynch | New York City | 24 | Miss New York City |
| 2002 | Tiffany Walker | Brooklyn | 22 | Miss New York City |
| 2001 | Andrea Plummer | New York City | 23 | Miss New York City |
| 2000 | Kelly Falgiano | Lancaster | 21 | Miss Amherst |
| 1999 | Brandi Burkhardt | Pasadena, Maryland | 20 | Miss Manhattan |
| 1998 | Deana Herrera | Staten Island | 20 | Miss Staten Island |
| 1997 | Lisa Esler | Northville | 21 | Miss Fulton County |
| 1996 | Tammy Harris | Williamstown | 24 | Miss Oswego County |
| 1995 | Sunita Param | Buffalo | Miss Buffalo | |
| Helen Goldsby | Brooklyn | 24 | Miss Orange County | |
| 1994 | Dione Lee Robinson | Gansevoort | 21 | Miss Capital Region |
| 1993 | Marcia Cillan | New York City | 23 | Miss Manhattan |
| 1992 | Ingrid Olsen | Port Jefferson | 22 | Miss Greater Syracuse |
| 1991 | Marisol Montalvo | Holbrook | 23 | Miss Long Island |
| 1990 | Maryalice Demler | Buffalo | 26 | Miss Buffalo |
| 1989 | Lisa Marie Molella | Millbrook | 24 | Miss Dutchess County |
| 1988 | Mia Seminoff | New York City | 23 | Miss Manhattan |
| 1987 | Alice Knisley | Staten Island | 21 | Miss Metropolitan New York City |
| 1986 | Dawan McPeak | New York City | 25 | Miss Metropolitan New York City |
| 1985 | Jill Privateer | Fredonia | 21 | Miss Buffalo |
| 1984 | Mary-Ann Farrell | New York City | 22 | Miss Manhattan |
| 1983 | Melissa Manning | |||
| Vanessa Williams | Millwood | 20 | Miss Greater Syracuse | |
| 1982 | Eileen Clark | Syracuse | 23 | Miss Greater Syracuse |
| 1981 | Suzanne Alexander | Lyons Falls | 20 | Miss Oneida County |
| 1980 | Cheryl Flanagan | Rochester | 18 | Miss Greater Rochester |
| 1979 | Kelli Krull | Buffalo | 21 | Miss Niagara Falls |
| 1978 | Paula Pope | Lockport | 21 | Miss Greater Colonie |
| 1977 | Lesly Braun | Pelham Manor | 23 | Miss Staten Island |
| 1976 | Sonja Anderson | New York City | 25 | Miss Manhattan |
| 1975 | Mary Hinterberger | |||
| Tawny Godin | Yonkers | 18 | Miss Saratoga Springs | |
| 1974 | Kris Krull | Niagara Falls | 22 | Miss Erie County East |
| 1973 | Joann Miller | Cheektowaga | 20 | Miss Erie County East |
| 1972 | Judith Keithley | Rochester | 19 | Miss Rochester |
| 1971 | Elisabeth Condon | Angola | 21 | Miss Niagara Falls |
| 1970 | Katherine Karlsrud | Mamaroneck | 18 | Miss Westchester |
| 1969 | Linda Trybus | Snyder | 20 | Miss Amherst |
| 1968 | Patricia Burmeister | Portville | 24 | Miss Rochester |
| 1967 | Kari Pedersen | Staten Island | 21 | Miss Staten Island |
| 1966 | Penelope Donoghue | Yonkers | 22 | Miss Westchester |
| 1965 | Marlene Butcher | Hamburg | 19 | Miss Dunkirk |
| 1964 | Julie Just | Buffalo | 20 | Miss Tri-County |
| 1963 | Barbara Gloede | New York City | Miss Dunkirk-Fredonia | |
| Marsha Metrinko | New York City | |||
| 1962 | Paula Heins | Le Roy | 19 | Miss Batavia |
| Margaret Mary Warncke | Flushing | 22 | ||
| 1961 | Kathryn Moden | Buffalo | 20 | Miss West Seneca |
| Maryann Hillyer | New York City | 20 | ||
| 1960 | Susan Talbert | Ogdensburg | 19 | Miss Dunkirk-Fredonia |
| Sherrylyn Patecell | Flushing | 19 | ||
| 1959 | Bonnie Jo Marquis | Huntington | 19 | |
| Elizabeth Holmes | Malverne | 19 | ||
| 1958 | Miriam Sanderson | Rensselaer | ||
| Bette June Piller | New York City | |||
| 1957 | Janet Corrigan | Huntington | ||
| Astrid Papamichael | New York City | |||
| 1956 | Lael Jackson | New York City | ||
| 1955 | Diana Deutsch | New York City | ||
| 1954 | Heather Taferner | New York City | ||
| 1953 | Jeannine Bowman | Rome | ||
| Joan Kaible | New York City | |||
| 1952 | Joan St. John | Binghamton | ||
| Joan Kayne | New York City | |||
| 1951 | Louise Orlando | Syracuse | ||
| Sandy Scott | New York City | |||
| 1950 | Marilyn Reynolds | Syracuse | ||
| Phyllis Battleson | New York City | |||
| 1949 | Wanda Nalepa | New York City | ||
| Loreen Osgood | New York City | |||
| 1948 | M. Yvonne Fix | Niagara Falls | ||
| Connie Inge Ronde | New York City | |||
| 1947 | Carol Fredericks | Harrison | ||
| Lynn Faune | Brooklyn | |||
| Raven Malone | New York City | |||
| 1946 | Violet Meller | White Plains | ||
| Eileen Henry | New York City | |||
| 1945 | June Jenkins | Elmont | ||
| Bess Myerson | New York City | 21 | ||
| 1944 | Bobby MacAdam | Brooklyn | ||
| Betty Jo Dazey | New York City | |||
| 1943 | Marion Butler | New York City | ||
| Milena Miller | New York City | |||
| 1942 | Marion Moselle | Utica | ||
| Catherine Victoria Zambon | ||||
| Annyse Sherman | New York City | |||
| 1941 | Charlotte Winstanley | |||
| Grace DeWitt | New York City | |||
| Lillian Helen O'Donnell | Yonkers | |||
| 1940 | Geraldine Anne Racine | |||
| Constantine Gray | Yonkers | |||
| Gloria Elizabeth Sheehan | Buffalo | |||
| 1939 | Grace M. Reilly | |||
| Clare E. Foley | ||||
| Lillian Evelyn Hesser | Annadale | |||
| 1938 | Elissa Winston | |||
| Barbara Beach | Brooklyn | |||
| Marion Rosamund | ||||
| Adeline Margaret Shull | ||||
| 1937 | Dorothy Armstrong | Whitesboro | ||
| Helen Fleiss | Bronx | |||
| Grace Travis | New York City | |||
| Irene Alice Vanderburgh | Watervliet | |||
| Evelyn Raye | New Rochelle | |||
| 1936 | Susan Georgianna Green | Bolwar | ||
| 1935 | Vera Haal | Bronx | ||
| Grace Tauss | Brooklyn | |||
| Laura Baker | Poughkeepsie | |||
| 1933 | Florence Meyers | 19 |
