Miss Indiana America Past Winners
Miss Indiana America Past Winners
| Year | Name | Hometown | Age | Local Title |
| 2011 | Jackie Jerlecki | Goshen | 22 | Miss Duneland |
| 2010 | Gabrielle Reed | Bloomington | 22 | Miss Southern Heartland |
| 2009 | Nicole Pollard | Lafayette | 23 | Miss Duneland |
| 2008 | Megan Meadors | Auburn | 22 | Miss Pride of Indiana |
| Katie Stam | Seymour | 22 | Miss Duneland | |
| 2007 | Nicole Rash | Plymouth | 23 | Miss Ball State University |
| 2006 | Betsy Uschkrat | Bloomington | 24 | Miss Indiana University |
| 2005 | Susan Guilkey | Noblesville | 22 | Miss North Central |
| 2004 | Sarah Wiley | Carmel | 24 | Miss Wabash Valley |
| 2003 | Bryn Chapman | Indianapolis | 21 | Miss South Central |
| 2002 | Tangra Riggle | West Lafayette | 21 | Miss North Central |
| 2001 | Allison Hatcher | Evansville | 24 | Miss North Central |
| 2000 | Betsy Bobel | Peru | 23 | Miss Duneland |
| 1999 | Kelly Lloyd | Indianapolis | 22 | Miss North Central |
| 1998 | Julianne Hackney | Vincennes | 20 | Miss Northwest Territory |
| 1997 | Sara Engerman | Kendallville | 19 | Miss Limberlost |
| 1996 | Shani Nielsen | New Albany | 24 | Miss Harvest Homecoming |
| 1995 | Becky Gray | Indianapolis | 23 | Miss North Central |
| 1994 | Tiffany Storm | Bloomington | 24 | Miss Capital City |
| 1993 | Dayna Brewer | New Albany | 22 | Miss Capital City |
| 1992 | Shelli Yoder | Shipshewana | 24 | Miss Elkhart |
| 1991 | Kari Hipsher | Wabash | 23 | Miss Huntington |
| 1990 | Brenda Bassett | Kokomo | 21 | Miss Kokomo |
| 1989 | Lisa Williamson | Terre Haute | 26 | Miss Hoosier Hills |
| 1988 | Joni McMechan | Liberty | 21 | Miss Central Indiana |
| 1987 | Sheila Stephen | Unionville | 23 | Miss Hoosier Hills |
| 1986 | Susan Sailor | Elkhart | 20 | Miss Elkhart |
| 1985 | Laurie Broderick | Elkhart | 21 | Miss Elkhart |
| 1984 | Cynthia Yantis | Fort Wayne | 23 | Miss Fort Wayne |
| 1983 | Teri Schultz | Bloomington | 21 | Miss Hoosier Hills |
| 1982 | Ilona Conway | Bunker Hill | 25 | Miss Hoosier Hills |
| 1981 | Pam Carlberg | Bourbon | 21 | Miss Plymouth |
| 1980 | Teri Kardatzke | Anderson | 19 | Miss Anderson |
| 1979 | Rickee Farrell | Valparaiso | 18 | Miss North Central |
| 1978 | Terry Kaiser | Etna Green | 22 | Miss Plymouth |
| 1977 | Barbara Mougin | Bremen | 24 | Miss Plymouth |
| 1976 | Tamara Trittschuh | Plainfield | 21 | Miss Monroe County |
| 1975 | Cyndi Legler | Fort Wayne | 21 | Miss Mid-Central |
| 1974 | Penny Tichenor | Owensville | 21 | Miss Evansville Freedom Festival |
| 1973 | Karen Rogers | Indianapolis | 22 | Miss Indiana Central College |
| 1972 | Rebecca Graham | Indianapolis | 23 | Miss South Central |
| 1971 | Pat Patterson | Gary | 22 | Miss Gary |
| 1970 | Debbie May | Remington | 21 | Miss Indianapolis |
| 1969 | Jill Jackson | Anderson | 18 | Miss Anderson |
| 1968 | Kit Field | Indianapolis | 21 | Miss Indianapolis |
| 1967 | Mary Haglund | Indianapolis | 19 | Miss Butler University |
| 1966 | Jane Ann Rutledge | Vincennes | 19 | Miss Indiana University |
| 1965 | Eileen Smith | Indianapolis | 18 | Miss Indianapolis |
| 1964 | Sandra Miller | Bedford | 20 | Miss Bedford |
| 1963 | Marsha Pinkstaff | Crawfordsville | Miss Butler University | |
| 1962 | Julia Flaningan | Lebanon | 20 | Miss Butler University |
| 1961 | Kathleen Burke | Terre Haute | 18 | Miss Indiana State Teachers College |
| 1960 | Tommye Glaze | Culver | 21 | Miss Plymouth |
| 1959 | Barbara Kummer | Valparaiso | 20 | Miss Valparaiso University |
| 1958 | Anita Hursh | Goshen | Miss Goshen | |
| 1957 | Gloria Rupprecht | Valparaiso | Miss Valparaiso University | |
| 1956 | Mary McNulty | Fort Wayne | Miss Fort Wayne | |
| 1955 | Carolyn Turner | Indianapolis | Miss Indianapolis | |
| 1954 | Sue Eaton | Monticello | Miss Indianapolis | |
| 1953 | Violet Wratich | East Chicago | Miss East Chicago | |
| 1952 | Ann Garnier | Indianapolis | Miss Indianapolis | |
| 1951 | Carol Mitchell | Rochester | Miss Rochester | |
| 1950 | Pat Berry | Indianapolis | Miss Monticello | |
| 1949 | Patricia Cunningham | Peru | Miss Monticello | |
| 1948 | Patti Grubbs | Gary | ||
| 1947 | Beverly Trenary | Gary | ||
| 1946 | Lois Chitwood | Helmsburg | Miss Indiana University | |
| 1945 | Betty Lockyear | Evansville | ||
| 1941 | Alice Ullery | Evansville | ||
| 1940 | Carolyn Akin | Evansville | ||
| 1938 | Helen Emly | Letts | Miss Letts | |
| 1927 | Hilda Koch | South Bend | Miss South Bend |
