Miss Connecticut America 2012
| Year | Name | Hometown | Age | Local Title |
| 2011 | Morgan Amarone | Hamden | 23 | Miss Southington |
| 2010 | Brittany Decker | Bristol | 21 | Miss Hartford County |
| 2009 | Sharalynn Kuziak | Southington | 22 | Miss Constitution |
| 2008 | Ashley Glenn | Hamden | 23 | Miss Shoreline |
| 2007 | Dana Daunis | Watertown | 22 | Miss Fairfield County |
| Lauren Betancourt | Suffield | Miss North Haven | ||
| 2006 | Heidi Alice Voight | Milford | 24 | Miss Capital Region |
| 2005 | Dianna Baitinger | Norwich | 23 | Miss North Haven |
| 2004 | Nikki Palmieri | North Haven | 22 | Miss Montowese |
| 2003 | Marla Prete | North Haven | 22 | Miss Fairfield County |
| 2002 | Tanisha Brito | New London | 22 | Miss New London County |
| 2001 | Marissa Perez | Meriden | 23 | Miss Fairfield County |
| 2000 | Renelle Richardson | Branford | 18 | Miss Elm City |
| 1999 | Sylvia Gomes | Bridgeport | 20 | Miss Hamden |
| 1998 | Lauren Bergamo | Prospect | 19 | Miss Hamden |
| 1997 | Merissa Starnes | Bloomfield | 21 | Miss Nutmeg |
| 1996 | Stacy Perrone | Wolcott | 22 | Miss Wolcott |
| 1995 | Amy Zappone | Wolcott | 18 | Miss Wolcott |
| 1994 | MaryGrace Santagata | New Haven | 24 | Miss Charter Oak |
| 1993 | Kimberly Burgess | Manchester | 22 | Miss Waterbury |
| 1992 | Valorie Abate | North Haven | 22 | Miss New Haven County |
| 1991 | Stephanie Stiefel | West Haven | 26 | Miss New Haven County |
| 1990 | Bianca Salahashourian | Fairfield | 25 | Miss Greater Waterbury |
| 1989 | Marlena Marshall | Glastonbury | 25 | Miss Vernon |
| 1988 | Maria Caporale | Oakdale | 24 | Miss New London County |
| 1987 | Michele Eaton | Shelton | 21 | Miss Fairfield County |
| 1986 | Lorraine Hudson | North Haven | 24 | Miss Briarwood College |
| 1985 | Lorine Guagenti | Derby | 21 | Miss New Haven County |
| 1984 | Joanne Caruso | Trumbull | 23 | Miss Trumbull |
| 1983 | Dakeita Vanderburg | Westport | 26 | Miss Westport |
| 1982 | Kelly Slater | Woodbury | 21 | Miss Woodbury |
| 1981 | Virginia Reichardt | Danbury | 21 | Miss Danbury |
| 1980 | Jeanne Caruso | Trumbull | 21 | Miss Trumbull |
| 1979 | Laura Kaufmann | Enfield | 18 | Miss Greater Enfield |
| 1978 | Maryalice Flintroy | Meriden | 18 | Miss Meriden |
| 1977 | Karen Kopins | Ridgefield | 18 | Miss Ridgefield |
| 1976 | Debra LaRoche | Cheshire | 20 | Miss Cheshire |
| 1975 | Mary Cadorette | East Hartford | 18 | Miss Manchester |
| 1974 | Elisa Heinemann | Wethersfield | 18 | Miss Wethersfield |
| 1973 | Deborah Blanchard | North Haven | 21 | Miss New Haven |
| 1972 | Linda Kapral | East Lyme | 19 | Miss East Lyme |
| 1971 | Priscilla Doyle | Rockville | 23 | Miss Manchester |
| 1970 | Cynthia Fowler | Cheshire | 21 | Miss Cheshire |
| 1969 | Carol Jean Norval | Stafford Springs | 21 | Miss Stafford |
| 1968 | Gunnell Ragone | West Hartford | 21 | Miss University of Hartford |
| 1967 | Diane Bylo | Norwalk | 21 | Miss Stamford |
| 1966 | Carole Gelish | |||
| 1965 | Donna Scott | Stratford | 18 | Miss Danbury |
| 1964 | Honora Bukowski | Wallingford | 18 | Miss Wallingford |
| 1963 | Valerie Stetson | Milldale | Miss Southington | |
| 1962 | Diane DeMaio | Hartford | 18 | Miss Hartford |
| 1961 | Karen Scalise | Glastonbury | 18 | Miss East Hartford |
| 1960 | Wendy Mitchell | New Haven | 18 | Miss West Haven |
| 1959 | Diana Klug | Torrington | 21 | |
| 1958 | Billie Turner | New Canaan | ||
| 1957 | Susan Lightbown | Fairfield | ||
| 1956 | Joy Corrado | Torrington | ||
| 1955 | Audrey Figlar | Hartford | ||
| 1954 | Dorothy Hopkins | Storrs | ||
| 1953 | Sarah Middleton | Hartford | ||
| 1952 | Joyce Yeske | West Hartford | ||
| 1951 | Beverly Buriant | Bridgeport | ||
| 1950 | Renee Roy | Hartford | ||
| 1949 | Barbara Smetana | Bridgeport | ||
| 1948 | Fairfax Mason | Bridgeport | ||
| 1947 | Louise Bienvenu | Waterbury | ||
| 1946 | Joan Turner | West Haven | ||
| 1945 | Sylvia Shaw | Hartford | ||
| 1944 | Barbara Fisher | East Hartford | ||
| 1943 | Mary Rice | Hartford | ||
| 1942 | Alice Clifford | Burlington | ||
| 1941 | Daphne Gladding | Plymouth | ||
| 1940 | Dorothy Pickard | New Haven | ||
| 1939 | Frieda Lampar | Bridgeport | ||
| Catherine Harrison | Derby | |||
| 1938 | Blanche Hawley | Stratford | ||
| 1937 | Frances Greene | Milford | ||
| 1936 | Tilie Grey | Waterbury | ||
| Evelyn Lenhart | Greenwich | |||
| 1935 | Margaretta Kling | New Haven | ||
| Margaret Holmes | Hartford | |||
| Ruth S. Rubin | New Haven | |||
| Veronica Turosky | ||||
| Sonia Banka | Bridgeport | |||
| 1933-1934 | Marian Bergeron | West Haven | 15 | |
| 1927 | No Miss Connecticut | |||
| 1926 | No Miss Connecticut | |||
| 1925 | No Miss Connecticut | |||
| 1924 | No Miss Connecticut | |||
| 1923 | No Miss Connecticut | |||
| 1922 | No Miss Connecticut |
